31.10.1892 Auction Bonn; Richard Semmel, Berlin; offered at auction Muller, Amsterdam 21.11.1933, no. 18; sold for 1,950 hfl (according to Weltkunst, JG VII, No. 52/53 v. 24.12.1933); 1982 Gallery Rob. Kattenburg, Aerdenhout (RKD); 13.03.-04.04.1987 exhibited at the Kunst- und Einrichtungshaus May, Cologne; an advertisement in the world art v. March 1987 (RKD); 2000/2001 Exhibition "True Miracle", Cologne, cat. No. C 39, p. 290, as "private collection Cologne"; 15.05.2010 Auction Lempertz, Cologne, Lot 1641, sold for 20.000 EUR
